RDR2 Five Finger Fillet Minigame Guide

Our RDR2 Five Finger Fillet Table Game Guide will help you with playing this Mini Game along with tips and strategy to win.

Five Finger Fillet is a high-stakes mini-game in Red Dead Redemption 2, requiring lightning-fast reflexes and nerves of steel. Players must swiftly navigate a knife between their outstretched fingers, competing against an opponent for the highest score.

Beyond the thrill of the game, Five Finger Fillet offers an opportunity to earn money. However, the risk of losing your wager adds an element of excitement and challenge.

This guide provides essential tips and strategies to help you become a Five Finger Fillet champion in RDR2.

Five Finger Fillet Table Locations?

There are three locations where you can find the Five Finger Fillet table. The first is northeast to the New Hanover, a little west to Van Horn.

The second location is south of Valentine, just near the borders of Cumberland Forest. This is by far the easiest table to win.

The third and final location is south of Strawberry, near Hawks Eye Creek.

Besides these three locations, you can also play the mini-game at your main camp, but remember that it won’t always be available there as mini-games rotate between PokerBlackjackDominoes and more. The Five Finger Fillet table in the town of Strawberry is permanent.

How To Play Five Finger Fillet?

Five Finger Fillet is a pretty simple game. In this mini-game, Arthur must stretch his hand and lay it on the table. Then, he needs to stab the table between his fingers while avoiding cutting any of his fingers.

The rules to play this mini-game are pretty simple: (i) don’t press the wrong button, else you’ll cut your finger, and (ii) try to win two out of three rounds to win the pot.

Winning the game requires sharp tactical use. You need to follow the commands on the screen and closely observe your opponent when they first attempt to understand the order.

This game has three variations: classic, guts, and burnout. In the Classic Five Finger Fillet game, you will have five attempts to complete the laps faster than the opponent in RDR2. In Guts variation, you’ve unlimited attempts in 20 seconds of time limit, so there’s no room for mistakes. Lastly, in the Burnout, you get just one attempt and 30 seconds to complete the game.

How To Win

To beat your opponent’s time, players will have five chances in each round. This gives you some room to make mistakes. This also allows you to make a few mistakes when memorizing the button prompts.

Therefore, I encourage you to make a couple of mistakes to familiarize yourself with the prompts. Then, quickly press the buttons to beat your opponent’s time.

Avatar photo

Namra is a gaming enthusiast and guides writer, always looking to play AAA titles on day one, while her favorites being Last of Us, Uncharted series, Spiderman, Final Fantasy, and Alan Wake.